This was not the first time I've gathered at Gather... but it was the first time that I ordered a brandy old fashioned sour w/olives. The bartender, Dee, insisted that she made a pretty dang good one.
I'll be the judge of that.
She grabbed a highball and started with a packet of sugar, followed by large, red, fresh (can they be fresh?) maraschino cherries and an orange slice. She then added Peychaud's aromatic cocktail bitters.
So back to the cocktail making. Dee added the special flower bitters, followed by the traditional Angostura bitters, and then muddled all the items together. She carefully smelled the drink and added more bitters. That is a good sign!
She then added a tall pour of Korbel and squeeze in two lemon slices and topped the drink with seltzer water.
Ultimately, I want to give Dee a 5 olive review, but my past experiences at Gather have not been worthy of that. So average it is. If Dee sticks around for awhile and other areas improve, this might be the first place I change a rating.
Rating (out of 5 olives)
213 S Nicolet Rd, Appleton